Can mollies live with platies?
Yes: mollies and platies can share a tank. Their water ranges overlap (70–79 °F / 21–26 °C, pH 7–8.2) and the calculator finds no behaviour problem. Plan at least 21 gal / 80 L for the two species together.
Molly vs Platy: side by side
| Molly | Platy | |
|---|---|---|
| Adult size | 3.9 in / 10 cm | 2.4 in / 6 cm |
| Minimum tank | 21 gal / 80 L | 14 gal / 54 L |
| Group | at least 3 | at least 3 |
| Temperature | 70–82 °F / 21–28 °C | 68–79 °F / 20–26 °C |
| pH | 7–8.5 | 7–8.2 |
| Swims at the | middle | middle |
| Temperament | peaceful | peaceful |
Water ranges and behaviour from the species data used by the Aqualitro calculator (based on Seriously Fish).
How many of each?
The smallest common tank that fits both is a 29-gallon tank. With 3 mollies and 3 platies, it is about 58% stocked (comfortable maximum: 75%). There is still room for a few more fish. Check your own mix in the stocking calculator.